![](themes/SoT/BG_Moon_4a.jpg)
![Sea Of Tranquility](themes/SoT/SoT_FB_header.jpg)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Envy Of None: Envy Of None
It’s interesting that when I cue up the songs on Envy Of None’s self titled debut album on i-tunes, the music platform informs me that this album is an ‘unknown genre’. That, for me, would be taking things too far, and instead what I’d suggest is that rather than the collaboration between guitarist Alex Lifeson (Rush), bassist Andy Curran (Coney Hatch), vocalist Maiah Wynne and guitarist Alfio Annibalini being some new fangled style of music, it’s simply unconcerned by genre boxing. Instead, this album veers - within an admittedly tight framework - from mood to mood as it takes in slick pop music, prog rock, industrial, art-rock and much else in between.
Wynne, it has to be said is something of a find and it’s no wonder that when Lifeson heard her sing he immediately knew who the front-person of his first post Rush band would be. She really is quite magnificent, with companions being made to Elizabeth Fraser (Cocteau Twins) not being too far from the mark in many ways. In the dreamy but angular setting of “Look Inside” she’s the absolute centre of everything going on around her and as the album slides into the mid-paced industrial prog-metal of “Liar” so too does she shine dazzlingly here also.
For those expecting the resumes of either Lifeson or Curran to be vaguely relevant here, Envy Of None will be something of a shock, but with Rush being peerless prog pioneers and Coney Hatch underusing catchy rock masters, what would be the point in aping either? Therefore that this album feels like a left turn for both should be welcome and admired. And yet, that doesn’t automatically ensure that it should also be loved by those most likely to be drawn towards what’s been put together. That’s not to say that Rush or Hatch fans won’t find much to enjoy, but on a purely personal level, I have to admit to feeling like this album is already ten, if not more, years behind the curve, with the mid-paced industrial meander you’ll unearth here already a scene that’s come and gone. And when you add in that for the most part Lifeson’s guitar work feels as buried as it was in 80s era Rush - the solo on “Spy House” being an obvious exception - then that feels like a little bit of a waste. Of course, the other way of looking at that would be that if the songs don’t require a blistering guitar solo - and there’s no doubt that the clatter and swoon of “Dog’s Life” or the closing acoustic strum of “Western Sunset” do not - then surely the more admirable option would be to resist simply welding on aspects that don’t belong to satisfy those who might well crave them?
There’s no doubt that moving on from a lifelong and worshipped endeavour is a near impossible task and I’d argue that if you’re going to even attempt that feat, then something entirely different is required. Envy Of None is indeed entirely different to anything that’s come previously from Alex Lifeson, or for that matter Andy Curran. That in itself is something to be celebrated, but at the same time it doesn’t always follow that it results in an album I’m going to personally be drawn back to time and again.
Track Listing
1. Never Said I Love You
2. Shadow
3. Look Inside
4. Liar
5. Spy House
6. Dog`s Life
7. Kabul Blues
8. Old Strings
9. Dumb
10. Enemy
11. Western Sunset
Added: May 8th 2022 Reviewer: Steven Reid Score: ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_half.gif) Related Link: Envy Of None online Hits: 1176 Language: english
[ Printer Friendly Page ] [ Send to a Friend ] |
|
[ Back to the Reviews Index ]
|
|
» SoT Staff Roundtable Reviews: |
Envy Of None: Envy Of None Posted by Pete Pardo, SoT Staff Writer on 2022-05-09 00:01:21 My Score: ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif)
Here we have the new band/project from Rush guitarist Alex Lifeson, Envy of None, which also features bassist Andy Curran (Coney Hatch), vocalist Maiah Wynne, guitarist Alfio Annibalini, plus a handful of guys playing drums and various other instruments. After listening to this album a few times, and reading that Lifeson doesn't plan on doing any touring with Envy of None if they do go out on the road, I'm guessing this will fall more into the 'project' camp than become an actual band. As for the music of this self-title debut, good luck trying to classify this as anything resembling what fans of Rush or even Coney Hatch would even suspect. Much of what we get here is dreamy, electronic & ambient pop and industrial music, Wynne's quite lovely vocals floating over the top of layered and lush arrangements that, oddly enough, offer up very little guitar oomph considering you have both Lifeson and Annibalini on board here. In fact, if you knew nothing about Envy of None, you'd be hard pressed to identify Lifeson on much of this album. Sure, there are some cool riffs that you are hear through the bubbling synth haze on "Liar", and "Dog's Life" tries to uncover some hard rock muscle, but for the most part this is more a vocal/synth/bass album than a guitar rock record, and I'd say there is way less Alex Lifeson on Envy of None than on keyboard heavy Rush albums like Hold Your Fire and Power Windows. That being said, "Never Said I Love You" is a great, catchy song, and the dark "Enemy" walks the fine line between synth pop and heavy industrial quite nicely, but after a few listens Envy of None sadly probably won't find itself getting much more attention around here.
1. Never Said I Love You
2. Shadow
3. Look Inside
4. Liar
5. Spy House
6. Dog`s Life
7. Kabul Blues
8. Old Strings
9. Dumb
10. Enemy
11. Western Sunset
|
|
Envy Of None: Envy Of None Posted by on 2022-05-02 20:05:29 My Score: ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif) ![](images/star_whole.gif)
The Cocteau Twins reference is definitely one that I would make when listening to this. The album the Cocteau Twins made with Harold Budd ‘The Moon and the Melodies’ in 1986 is very much a sonic touchstone for this album, which incidentally is growing on me with every listen.
|
|
|
|
|
|
![](images/logos/SoT-Nuke.gif) 2004 Sea Of Tranquility | For information regarding where to send CD promos and advertising, please see our FAQ page.
If you have questions or comments, please Contact Us.
Please see our Policies Page for Site Usage, Privacy, and Copyright Policies.
|
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all other content Sea of Tranquility
SoT is Hosted by SpeedSoft.com ![](images/speedsoft_flag.gif)
|
|